top of page
Search

🚔 Why Removing Unlicensed & Uninsured Drivers Isn’t Slashing Uninsured Motorist Rates

ree

1. We're Clearing the Streets—but Insurers Aren’t Seeing That Yet

Enforcement may be removing drivers who lack licenses or insurance, but insurers are forward-looking. They need sustained, multi-year trend data before lowering your uninsured motorist premiums.


2. Florida Still Leads with Alarmingly High Rates of Uninsured Drivers

  • The Insurance Research Council (IRC) puts Florida’s uninsured driver rate at 20.6% in 2023—about one in five drivers—well above the U.S. average of 15.4% (III).

  • Earlier estimates put the rate as high as 26.7%, showing historical variability but consistently elevated risk (flafirm.com).


3. South Florida: A Hotspot for Driving Without License or Insurance

While precise current data for South Florida alone is sparse, enforcement records and anecdotal reporting confirm that many drivers in Miami-Dade are operating vehicles without valid licenses or insurance—some court filings estimate ~600,000 people in that county with suspended or no licenses (Reddit). Reddit testimonies reflect widespread noncompliance:

“We have many drivers that don’t have licenses and are uninsured. But they still are out there driving.” (Reddit).


4. Even a Smaller Pool of Violators Hurts Premiums Majorly

Though enforcement improves, a small number of uninsured or unlicensed drivers—particularly those involved in hit-and-runs or staged accidents—can inflict outsized losses. This keeps premiums from dropping, even when overall numbers decline.


5. Legal Risks and Insurance Architecture in Florida

  • Florida is a no-fault auto insurance state. Your own PIP kicks in first, and uninsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage helps if the other driver lacks insurance or minimum liability limits (ABC Action News Tampa Bay (WFTS), III).

  • The cost of UM/UIM coverage is baked into policies because claim frequency remains high thanks to uninsured and underinsured drivers—even among insured drivers only carrying Florida’s low minimum limits. (Florida Policy Project, injurylawyers.com).



📊 Key Figures Snapshot

Metric

Florida

Uninsured driver rate (2023, IRC data)

20.6% (1 in 5 drivers)

Historical high estimates of uninsured

Up to 26.7% in prior studies

Drivers cited with suspended/no license

~600,000 in Miami-Dade County



🔍 Bottom Line

Even with enforcement targeting unlicensed and uninsured motorists, the relative risk pool hasn’t fallen enough. Insurers still see high claim frequency, inflated repair/medical costs, fraud, and legal exposure. Until those trends prove to be reliably lower over years, premiums will remain high.


✅ Action Plan: Turn Enforcement Into Lower Rates

  • Collect Data: Track citations and enforcement numbers specific to your city or county.

  • Advocate: Present these statistics to the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, lawmakers, and consumer advocates.

  • Push for communication: Urge insurers and regulators to incorporate local enforcement improvements into rate-setting sooner.

  • Collaborate locally: Community groups, local officials, and businesses can form a coalition to demand a measureable system response.



Chairman Bob Sign‑Off: It’s great to see streets cleaner of unlicensed, uninsured drivers. But until premiums reflect that progress, the system hasn't fully caught on. Keep pushing. Believe in the data. And we’ll force the system to measure—and reward—real improvement.


Listen. Believe. Measure.


 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page